For new newsgroup readers, these are not our forum posts. Any comments to the posters below should be made on the applicable thread, marked in bold below.
FYI apologist itspostingtime posts spin and damage control for eBay ...
//
From eBay Stores Forum
eBAY .... I Thought You Were Fighting Scams
http://forums.ebay.com/db2/thread.jspa?threadID=2000424988&start=0
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:12 PDT
Just got around to reading the latest eBAY advertisement that came last week ----
I CAN NOT BELIEVE ---
That this mega corporation is encouraging its sellers to buy inventory for the holidays on the street and then use return policies to dump unused inventory back to the original store.
There is no defence for this total lack of ethics --- NONE
eBAY --
You are encouraging sellers to CHEAT -- BE DISHONEST -- and and to abuse the marketplace
I AM DISGUSTED
WANNA FIGHT FRAUD ?????
FIRE THE GENIUS WHO DEVISED THIS APALLING SCHEME !!!!!
Carl
.
dorothysew (834 ) Aug-27-07 09:14 PDT 1
Carl, could you explain abit? I didn't get the advertisement you are talking about.
Thanks
D
secondchancebuys (Private ) Aug-27-07 09:19 PDT 2
yes please explain.
career.curves (132 ) Aug-27-07 09:24 PDT 3
I would be very interested in reading this as well.
-Tammy
pins-n-needles (3237 ) Aug-27-07 09:25 PDT 4
Crumb. I just deleted my email - I think that one was in it. Was it the last 'seller central' email?
I think I deleted it without opening it as usually there's nary a thing that has any pertinance to me or what I sell.
babybcp (918 ) Aug-27-07 09:25 PDT 5
It was in the PowerSellers Newsletter I think...
Jennifer
oas3 (14536 ) Aug-27-07 09:26 PDT 6
eBay's Newsletter Advice Ticks off Sellers:::
http://www.auctionbytes.com/cab/abn/y07/m08/i27/s01
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:28 PDT 7
Fall 2007 --- PowerUP Quarterly
REV UP Plans for a PROFITABLE Holiday
SOURCE RETAIL FOR BIG PROFITES
"Returns mean low risk --- When sourcing at retail check the return policy ..... You can always return the inventory if you find it does not sell ....."
Maybe we should all flock to the eBAY Store --
Carl
just-thinking (0 ) Aug-27-07 09:29 PDT 8
"I'm not sure just why eBay would give this advice in the current climate of retailers scrutinising eBay."
"Ebay Tells Sellers To Cheat Stores To Sell Merchandise On eBay!"
From that article
secondchancebuys (Private ) Aug-27-07 09:35 PDT 9
I am speechless.
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:37 PDT 10
We have B&M ----
If I caught on to a person using me as a consignment shop without proper agreements I would without any doubt bring a civil law suit ---
Would I win ??? DO NOT KNOW AND DO NOT CARE ---
I would pay the dollars to cause extreme public embarrasment to both the offender and the source of the idea ---
I have seen some outlandish schemes ---- This one ---
BY A HUGE INTERNET JUST A VENUE TURNED MARKETING COUNSELER absolutely takes the BLACK RIBBON of shame
I repeat --- The person who devised this grand idea ..
NEEDS TO BE PLACED IN A POSITION WHERE THEIR NOSE IS PRESSED AGAINST THE WINDOW LOOKING IN ....
AND YES I AM SCREAMING ----- eBAY has exceeded the basic boundaries of common decency ---
Carl
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:40 PDT 11
eBAY is requesting sellers to commit fraud ---
There is no way to sugar coat this ---
NOR SHOULD THEY TRY ---
eBAY should make a very public apology for when this gets widely decimated by the media -- AND IT WILL without any doubt -- Ina already has it ---- It will make there outcry ovewr scams to be a paper thin veneer and expose them as shameless - unethical - and extremely irresponsible
Carl
sewm4 (2 ) Aug-27-07 09:44 PDT 12
"Ebay Tells Sellers To Cheat Stores To Sell Merchandise On eBay!"
That is NOTa ebay quote it is a PARDOY
tiny-townersredux (0 ) Aug-27-07 09:48 PDT 13
It gets more and more bewildering. I just pulled the only good item I had listed on my main ID.
This site is only good for selling:
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:50 PDT 14
"Ebay Tells Sellers To Cheat Stores To Sell Merchandise On eBay!"
That is NOTa ebay quote it is a PARDOY
It is indeed a parody --- However that is exactly what the suggestion is encouraging sellers to do ---
There is no way to sugar coat or spin this outragous marketing scheme ----
WHATS NEXT ---
As a way to boost sell through will eBAY encorage buyers to buy fromn sellers on trial basis --- BUY IT YOU WILL LIKE IT -- IF NOT JUST RETURN IT AS NOT AS DESCRIBED --
This is effectively the same thing --- What the hey it will only cost the sellers a few bucks
Carl
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 09:52 PDT 15
Can someone give me the email addresses to Bill & Meg -- I will give them the benefit of doubt that they are so far removed from daily eBAY reality that they are unaware of what their market gurus have devised and its implications --
Carl
just-thinking (0 ) Aug-27-07 09:53 PDT 16
WHATS NEXT ---
As a way to boost sell through will eBAY encorage buyers to buy fromn sellers on trial basis --- BUY IT YOU WILL LIKE IT -- IF NOT JUST RETURN IT AS NOT AS DESCRIBED --
This is effectively the same thing --- What the hey it will only cost the sellers a few bucks
Don't give them any ideas Carl LOL
The buck stops at the top, sure fire whoever did
this but the CEO is ultimately responsible for this.
oas3 (14536 ) Aug-27-07 09:56 PDT 17
Carl whoever wrote that article as well as those above that approved it should be shown the door..
tiny-townersredux (0 ) Aug-27-07 09:56 PDT 18
Will they pay for the item, will it get any bids, will I get a chargeback, will I get a bogus feedback, will I get suspended, will I take it in the shorts if I start it too cheap, will the unsold fees eat up the sold profits, will I get my ad pulled, will my shipping get questioned??????
Et cetera.
Why is the River so simple and this place so complicated?
sandrarn83 (2769 ) Aug-27-07 09:56 PDT 19
Carl Ebay is offering a suggestion that many Ebayers already do. I am a shopaholic both for myself and my business. I know most of the store managers in every store I shop personally. Reason? When you spend a couple of thousand dollars somewhere in a hour or two they tend to remember you. I have heard this same complaint on a number of occasions by almost every store manager or owner. Usually in the context of "I don't mind selling to you because you don't bring it back". Seems this is a common tactic unfortunately. The large famous New York Avenue dept store people even have a sign in their outlet stores about resellers aren't provided the same return policy as the general public. They reserve the right to refuse to refund. Someone like myself stands out quite prominently when you buy 50-100 of something identical at one time.
Of course I agree with you. Unfortunately this is quite common a practice and yes I agree it's still wrong. Ebay is just trying to hook the newbies into selling on the site. Someone has to take the place of all the sellers who have left.
just-thinking (0 ) Aug-27-07 09:59 PDT 20
Imagine when all the stock analyst places find out
about this.
itspostingtime (2 ) Aug-27-07 10:01 PDT 21
Carl,
I've never done it. Wouldn't do it. But it's certainly not a new idea.
That's why I'm not shocked by this. Over the years, I've seen this SAME advice given by SELLERS on the Boards. As I recall, there's usually been a mixed response: some people view it as unethical, some people agreed with it and some acknowledged that they did it.
I can tell you, aside from ebay, this sort of thing is prevalent in, say, clothing stores, where buyers buy "special occassion clothes" (something to wear to a wedding, for example) and then return it after the affair is over.
I know of people who do this at their local GoodWill...they'll buy something, take it home, research closed auctions, and bring it back if they don't think they can sell it. And I know it happens in antique malls as well.
I find more products than glitches
neglus (16640 ) Aug-27-07 10:03 PDT 22
This is very unsettling. Can hardly wait to hear Hani Durzy's response to that one - hopefully there will be one along with an apology to all in the Community who are disgusted with this "tip". I suppose the tip that suggested shoplifting inventory (though this is really the same thing) got cut.
just-thinking (0 ) Aug-27-07 10:03 PDT 23
I think it is one thing to know others do it but
another thing to encourage others to do it.
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 10:06 PDT 24
Sandram83
I am sorry -- your tone is much to concilliatory ---
It was thing when an individual engages in these shenanigans -- NO LESS APPALLING -- NO LESS UNETHICAL ---
It is totally another when a VENUE recommends to its selling group that this is an acceptable business practice -- IF
This is acceptable -- WHY NOT the whole spectrum of dishonest practices --
Forgereries -- Stolen Goods -- Fakes --
It is now established that eBAY is willing to encourage unethical and fraudulant practices -- So where is the line -- or
Does this venue get to redifine decent business practice
Believe me the media will have this and by weeks end this will become a major black eye and butt of Letterman and Leno Jokes.
Not only that I am certain that some large compant retailing CEO's are discussing methods of combatting this -- and -0- just possibly they may involve manufactureres --
The potential; for harm is great -- and rightfully so
carl
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 10:12 PDT 25
Its posting time --
I do not care about any of that --
PLEASE -- You can not really believe that what others do is an excuse for wrong doing --
eBAY is trying to set itself as the white knight in cleaning this place up -- This suggestion does not set a very good example --
THERE IS NO WAY TO DEFEND THIS -- NONE
It exposes a very seamy ethical leadership that calls into question any effort eBAY makes to fix other unethical practices by its sellers --- IT REMOVES ALL CREDABILITY about eBAYS efforts to clean this sight up.
It is a call to commit fraud --- and there is really no other way to describe it --- NONE -- It may well border on an illegal act called scheme to defraud which in NY is a class D Felony I believe ---
It is NO LESS THAN STEALING -- and I do not care if it is in practice now -- THOSE WHO DO IT WITHOUT THE STORES KNOWLEDGE ARE STEALING --
carl
classy_crafter (358 ) Aug-27-07 10:20 PDT 26
Ive bought retail and resold it for a profit. But never ever would I return it. Its just wrong and unethical.
I cant believe eBay would actually encourage such unethical and fraudulent behavior.
"I don't believe in a government that protects us from ourselves." - Ronald Reagan
classy_crafter (358 ) Aug-27-07 10:21 PDT 27
Carl,
You are right. I bet you the CEOs of all the major retailers are brainstorming about how to combat this situation and how to distinguish someone buying for themselves vs an eBay seller. Who to refund and who to refuse to refund.
Things will end up changing, and not for the greater good I am afraid.
"I don't believe in a government that protects us from ourselves." - Ronald Reagan
ocean2tides (801 ) Aug-27-07 10:22 PDT 28
yes, this is done by some sellers.
But the idea that EBAY itself would RECOMMMEND and ENCOURAGE sellers do it is unconscionable.
Are they going to recommend and encourage the buyers of my ebay products to do that, too?
They want to get major advertisers to their site (macy's, target, etc.). Wonder how they will view this?
WHAT is WRONG with these people at ebay? Where do they find these employees? A company shows it's true side by the employees they hire. This speaks volumes about, not only the employees, but the leadership at ebay.
SHAME on ebay!
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 10:26 PDT 29
I am attending a meeting of local business people Wednesday evening -- In this group are several store managers from local stores including several that might be subjected to this scheme --
I will poll them to see how they feel about this particular method of aquiring inventory -- their reeaction should they catch someone ewngaging in the activity -- and will also try to get some general comments.
I DOUBT THEY ARE in favor of purchasing inventory -- then consigning it to an eBAY seller with an if it does not sell you do not have to pay for it guarentee -- I think they will be very distressed at the thought of a large scale competitor encouraging its "associates" to engage in such a practice --- and --
I will be very surprised if they will publicly or privately condone it -- or -- name it anything other than outright deceptive or worse.
I will report back the reactions on Thursday or Friday --
carl
sandrarn83 (2769 ) Aug-27-07 10:29 PDT 30
Go for it Carl. By the way that store manager for the New York Ave dept store people hates me. He reported me to headquarters for purchasing in "his store" for resale. Headquarters in turn started INCREASING the lingerie supplied to that local store. He still hates me he just has to grit his teeth and tolerate me now because NY loves me. Some companies obviously like resellers others do not. I think you will find the small B&M store owners are the ones worst affected by this tacky idea.
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 10:33 PDT 31
Sandram83
I see absolutely nothing wrong with purchsing locally or wherever for resale
THAT is not the same thing at all -- People who purchase for resale and return are abusing the retailer --- It is no less unethical than stealing -- after all when this methodology is used --
The retailer has had any opportunity to sell the item stolen from them --- There is no defense -- It is what it is.
carl
oakstrom (3567 ) Aug-27-07 10:39 PDT 32
Funny thing is i do believe the major retailers are in the process of changing there return policies to one much more conditional and restrictive, as the number of returns is really biting into the margins.
It would be too funny if those people that follow ebay's underhand advice, find the stores are not going to refund carte blanche this selling season.
Really would be nice to see Ebay roasted for this "glitch"
Oakstrom
mygift2u (6701 ) Aug-27-07 10:44 PDT 33
That letter to toally unethical. Someone needs to fire the person that dreamed that one up!
Unbelieveable!
mygift2u (6701 ) Aug-27-07 10:44 PDT 34
Sorry, should have read - That letter IS totally unethical
ocean2tides (801 ) Aug-27-07 10:46 PDT 35
Sandra,
You buy at the stores, but don't return the merchandise.
That is the difference.
EBAY has recommended that it's sellers buy and RETURN if it doesn't sell for a profit.
Can you imagine if ebay recommended your ebay customers do the same? They buy from you (or other ebay sellers), if it doesn't sell for enough when they list it, they should return it to you, the ebay seller.
IT'S THE EXACT SAME THING.
SHAME on ebay.
mygift2u (6701 ) Aug-27-07 10:48 PDT 36
To clarify -
What a seller does is the sellers business BUT encouraging buying with the sole intention of returning an item to a retail store if it does not sell on eBay is totally unconscionable. Ebay should NEVER have put this in print.
HEY eBay - If I list an item in CORE and it does not sell can I "put it back in MY eBay STORE for FREE???????
What is the difference??
lucysfabrics (2332 ) Aug-27-07 11:05 PDT 37
Nice work, eBay! That's why a lot of major retailers are tightening up return policies and charging restocking fees. Pretty soon regular people won't be able to return for legitimate reasons.
Stuff like that is why I don't tell people I sell on eBay.
faeries_finest (870 ) Aug-27-07 11:20 PDT 38
It's a common trap that Ebay fell into - mistaking what you can do for what you should do.
Yes, people can return items they buy at retail stores but it isn't an automatic pass. There are circumstances where you shouldn't return and buying to resell is definitely one of them.
It's also perpetuating the myth that you can engage in business risk free. No, you can't. You take chances. You make your best decision as to which direction to take your business and what to sell but there aren't guarantees.
So - what are the odds that Ebay will admit it was poor advice???
Faerie
faerie's finest - enchanting your life with flavor
oldspartantrader (2944 ) Aug-27-07 11:29 PDT 39
So - what are the odds that Ebay will admit it was poor advice
When they are forced to do so by the fall out that I am certain is coming they will do so -- It will beblamed on some low level employer and couched in terms such as --
We have taken measure to ensure -- This was a glaring error by our editorial people and should have been caught -- We in know way condone such a practice as company policy --- BUT
That is all defensive and the damage will be done --- AND
If consumers are informed by media about the implications to them and their normal use of the return mechanisms -- there may well be additional backlash --
The proper thing at this point is contact recipients of the article and apologize and admit error -- To contact some key media people and cut the publicity off at the pass -- This might even allow eBAY to be seen as humble and caring LOL --
It will also be a premtive strike that will make any bouhaha just old news and give them the ability to point to how proactive they are in cleaning upo issues wiuth the sight ---
If I was a media person I would be having an absolute field day with this --- If I had an axe to gring I would be honing it -- AND YOU CAN BET many out there do and are.
Carl
appliancecoverqueen (178 ) Aug-27-07 11:33 PDT 40 of 47
"When sourcing at retail, check the return policy before you buy. If items are returnable, you can always return the inventory if you find it doesn't sell at a good profit."
HOLY CARP? What the heck is wrong with this company. They encourage sellers to be unethical and then install a ridiculous star system rating that unethical people can hide behind. Can they do anything more to destroy their reputation with sellers?
Judy
just-thinking-2 (0 ) Aug-27-07 11:37 PDT 41 of 47
If I was a media person I would be having an absolute field day with this --- If I had an axe to gring I would be honing it -- AND YOU CAN BET many out there do and are.
Bet you are right. I bet there are many people out
there writing the news, blogs, stock analysts, etc.
etc. etc. And if not yet, I bet it will be very
soon.
batches2007 (704 ) Aug-27-07 11:38 PDT 42 of 47
I feel like a deck hand on the Titanic with no room in the lifeboats...
swimwear-maternity-more (467 ) View Listings | Report Aug-27-07 11:44 PDT 43 of 47
Here us an article that Auction Bytes wrote about these very issues. There is an on-going article regarding the issues of eBay sellers buying merchandise from certain retail stores and outlets and are being banned from buying from them or have limits on how many items they can purchase.
Here is the article on Auction Bytes:
http://www.auctionbytes.com/cab/abn/y07/m08/i27/s01
This is a very interesting topic.
Erna
swimwear-maternity-more (467 ) Aug-27-07 11:49 PDT 44 of 47
I meant: Here is an article
spelling errors
career.curves (132 ) Aug-27-07 11:49 PDT 45 of 47
In all seriousness, I'm off to change my return policy and I'm removing my 100% satisfaction guarantee.
-Tammy
big_sapper (140 ) View Listings | Report Aug-27-07 11:53 PDT 46 of 47
Anyone rememebr the Seinfeld episode where Jerry returns the jacket to the clothing store?
...
JERRY: Excuse me I'd like to return this jacket.
TELLER: Certainly. May I ask why?
JERRY: ........For spite...
TELLER: Spite?
JERRY: That's right. I don't care for the salesman that sold it to me.
TELLER: I don't think you can return an item for spite.
JERRY: What do you mean?
TELLER: Well if there was some problem with the garment. If it were unsatisfactory in some way, then we could do it for you, but I'm afraid spite doesn't fit into any of our conditions for a refund
JERRY: That's ridiculous, I want to return it. What's the difference what the reason is.
TELLER: Let me speak with the manager...excuse me .............Bob!
(walks over to the manager and whispers)
TELLER: ........spite.....(Manager walks over)
BOB: What seems to be the problem?
JERRY: Well I want to return this jacket and she asked me why and I said for spite and now she won't take it back.
BOB: That's true. You can't return an item based purely on spite.
JERRY:. Well So fine then ..then I don't want it and then that's why I'm returning it
BOB: Well you already said spite so......
JERRY: But I changed my mind..
BOB: No...you said spite...Too late.
world_securities (4952 ) Aug-27-07 11:58 PDT 47 of 47
Carl, now that you've seen eBay's other side, would you care to revise your earlier post?
eBay PR displays posts like this, as an example of how 'they can do no wrong'. So to speak.
http://forums.ebay.com/db2/thread.jspa?messageID=2007444775&forumID=21&x#2007444775
I feel that I am paying my fees for an opportunity at the BAZARRE'S traffic --- No More -- No Less -- and
there is tons of that traffic for me to tap into at this time -- I do not care if it is declining -- I do not care if it ceases totally at some point -- I will make the necessary adjustments at that time.
In essence too many people are still expecting eBAY to do more than eBAY is willing to --- MAYBE they used to --- PROBABLY the site was better --- It is waht IT is -- and the smart thing to do is to accept the is and make it -- If unable to make the present situation work it is important to recognize that unless you just want to spend money ---
For many that tipping point arrived --- YET rather than changing there model -- or moving on they seem to believe it will go back if enough old sellers scream ---
The only thing eBAY listens to is the KACHING --- As long as it rings loudly they are pleased --- I would be too
You take a very pragmatic attitude toward business. And people listen to you for that reason.
You should consider Everything you write in that vein.
"There actions hurt sellers --- BUT -- have not hurt the Corporation ---" oldspartantrader
/*
Technorati Profile
EventHorizon1984 Log
//